New BT FTTC offer Vs IDnet FTTC offerings

[mk1]

Having a pricing dilemma! To change from ADSL to FTTC, it appears BT offer a cheaper FTTC (infinity 1) than I am paying for IDnets ADSL (Pro) ~£37 vs ~£29, so before I drastically decide to go with BT! Any other good reasons for stick to IDnet (noting I am not going to pay £80 for FTTC upgrade, when i paid ~£150 a few mouths ago for the line install)

Just for ease the offer I have is 12.50 for BT Infinity 1 + TV (plus 16.99 line rental) 1yr contract then +£3 (minus TV) This is the capped fibre ~40MB verse IDnets 80MB

I'm not botherd by the TV part of the BT offer but any views on this would be welcome.

Thanks

[Steve]

What is your lines potential in terms of throughput ie if your can't much over 40 down it may influence your choice.

[mk1]

It suggests i could get the 80MB but I'm not sure thats really necessary,