Kitz ISP comparison

[Noreen]

I see that Kitz's site is now offering a ISP comparison page, another one to add to ThinkBroadband and DSL Zone UK. http://www.kitz.co.uk/adsl/ISP_ratings_compare.php

[Rik]

I see we're in joint first place, get rating people.

(I must get Tim to send a new logo across.)

[madasahatter]

That's useful to know Noreen - thanks

[Rik]

What are you still doing here, Mad, you should be over there voting. 

[madasahatter]

I'm not at home Rik, and it won't let me do it from work, but I promise faithfully I shall do my duty to the best of my ability as soon as humanly possible 

[Rik]

That's good enough for me.

[Noreen]

I see we're in joint first place, get rating people.

That was me. I did it as soon as I saw f2s in lone 1st place with 100% in all sections, they must be a member of staff, really got my goat.

[Rik]

Make that, "that was us", Noreen.

[Philip]

done my bit 

[Rik]

Well done that man, have a karma.

[J!ll]

Me too! 

[Rik]

There's clearly not much in the way of weighting in her rankings, F2S are still top on one rating, we're second. 

[J!ll]

Shall I vote again?! 

Nope, will have to do next month 

[Rik]

I suspect she's logging IP addresses and you won't be able to.

[Si]

Indeed, I just tried!

One rating a month per IP...

[J!ll]

Yep just what I posted, we overlapped 

[Noreen]

I see that we're in second place now. I just can't understand how f2s (Tiscali owned) is in first place with 100% in all sections although only with one rating and you wouldn't either if you read their forums like I do.

BTW how does it work that f2s has one rating for 100% and gets into first place while IDNet has more ratings for 100% but is in second place?

[Rik]

As I said, Noreen, Kitz isn't using a weighting system, just a pure 'average score'. Hopeless for evaluation, imo.

[BrianM]

Good find Noreen, just posted my two pence worth. 

[kinmel]

5*****s added (of course ) 

[Simon]

Voted! 

[Noreen]

So it seems that if nobody else rates f2s other than that one person they will remain 1st. And they sadly are now a 3rd rate Tiscali ISP.

[Sebby]

Just voted.

[J!ll]

We need more!

[Simon]

We need dynamic IPs!